We can’t all be Market Wizards. If I only interview the people who made it, you’d get a pretty distorted picture of what trading actually looks like. You hear about the years of struggle with the benefit of knowing how the story ends. The blown accounts and sleepless nights become a predictable beat of every successful trader’s origin story. But what about the other traders who only have blown accounts and sleepless nights while still waiting for the other side?
I started this series knowing I also wanted to interview the other 99%. The people still trying to figure it out. The breakout traders who have a huge year and spend the next two giving it back. The guys who study, keep records, find good mentors, and still can’t get over the hump. Some eventually make it. The vast majority quit. Some spend years getting just enough encouragement to keep going, without ever making enough money to justify what they’re putting into it. They live in a perpetual fog of war, not able to attain or even define *that one thing* that holds them back from consistent profitability.
That last group interests me because it’s an uncomfortable place to be. You can see yourself improving. You can explain your trades. You’re at least ahead of the newbs who just log onto reddit to buy meme stock call options. You’ve put enough time into this that quitting feels like throwing something away. You’re not blowing up. Meanwhile, your account is still bleeding, your actual career is getting less attention, and your family only gets whatever’s left of you after the close. At some point, you have to ask how much longer you’re willing to do this—and whether you’d even recognize it if the honest answer was to stop.
Krow was willing to talk about all of that while he’s still living it. He doesn’t yet have a profitable ending.
PETE: When did you start trading?
KROW: November 2020. Our workforce went fully remote during COVID, and I figured if I was ever going to give it a go, now was the time. I’ve been at it for six years and haven’t had any long-term success. Depending on what you include, I’m probably down about $60K with fees and everything. I might actually be profitable on a gross basis if you exclude all fees.

PETE: What was the first thing you tried?
KROW: A friend sent me a scalping course from a trading influencer named “ScalpWithJoe”1(not a real name). I’d wanted to trade for a while, but I didn’t know anything about the different markets or styles. The course was good for the basics, right down to what a candlestick is and how to read one. But I don’t think you could walk away from it and trade profitably. It was pure scalping, a lot of focus on P&L, emotions, and bragging. Not enough detail.

PETE: Did you get to see the ScalpWithJoe guy trade live?
KROW: That was a separate thing you paid him for. You could hear him on the mic, but there was no execution chart and you didn’t really know when he was getting in. I stuck with it for about a year, then left the room to try it on my own. By 2022, small caps were pretty dead and a lot of people jumped ship.
PETE: How’d you end up in small caps in the first place? Were you mostly shorting?
KROW: ScalpWithJoe traded small caps, so it was just a natural transition after I left. I set up the scans he talked about–top gainers, top % movers, most active–and traded what popped up. It was just short scalping. If something gapped and was in play, you’d look to short it and get a piece of the move.
Going into 2022, I met people who were doing more of a full mean reversion trade. You’d short it and hold most of the day. It worked for a little bit, and about a month after I got my head around it, there was barely anything in play. It was unfortunate timing.
PETE: What did you do after that?
KROW: We were looking for another market that was in play and I ended up dabbling in futures. I traded a little of everything, mostly ES day to day, and tried to copy what other people were doing. I got mixed up with those firms where you pay about $50 for an account and trade within their rules. I didn’t mind that part. It was basically a demo account I was paying for while I tried to learn. I had no edge, and I couldn’t find something I could do every day on ES and make money. When I heard small caps were coming back, I went back around late 2022 or early 2023.

PETE: Any changes you made when you came back? Did you have mechanical entries and exits?
KROW: I went back to shorting day-one gappers, looking for the same pattern and shorting it back to the mean. I wanted a repeatable way to trade without my emotions involved. The idea was that the scan hits, the stock pops up, and I know what I’m looking to short. I wasn’t doing opening-print stuff yet. I was messing around with indicators. It was probably EMA breaks or bar breaks. I feel like I’ve tried every indicator, and you can make most of them show you the pattern you want if you change the settings enough.
PETE: How long did you give that before you changed it up?
KROW: I spent pretty much all of 2023 on it. With a system, you can’t have one bad week and say it sucks. You have to see it through a cycle. I’d make an adjustment and give it three months. Then I’d change the stock selection, or think I should only trade stocks with dilution, and give it another three months. I still had discipline issues then. I’d tell myself I wasn’t trading sub-dollar stocks and then, when nothing else was popping, I’d trade them anyway. I was trying to work on that at the same time I was trying to figure out if the system worked.
I’ve never blown up. I usually risked against the highs or a little above, and I always wanted the risk set. I’d rather take a loss than win on something I gambled my way into. The account just bled. There was no upward direction in my equity curve that year. In 2024 and 2025, I started trying different styles and seeing what worked for other people.
PETE: And now you’re back to mean reversion?
KROW: Yeah. I was hardheaded about there being something there if I could get the system right. This year feels a lot like 2022 for the way I trade, but I hear myself saying, “Maybe next month it’ll pick up. Maybe next quarter. Maybe 2027.” At some point it feels like I’m making an excuse for every year it doesn’t work. Gamblers think they’re onto something too. I’ve got a family, a mortgage, a job. I’ve built this whole life that has now become consumed with failing at small caps.

PETE: Where do you even find the time with a full-time job and kids?
KROW: Before, it was easy. My wife and I were in a little apartment. We could skip dining out and I’d use that time to study. Now it’s chaos. I work remotely and sometimes I’m looking after one of my kids at the same time. I’ve become specialized enough in my job that I can get my work done quickly, but trading has eaten into career opportunities. I get my work done and immediately shift back to trading. I’m not pushing myself in my actual career.
It’s the same with family. I’m sacrificing time with my kids to study or to focus on executing in the morning. I’m okay sacrificing my own time and failing, but how do you stay present with your family when you’re 100% in trading? If I do badly for a month, I feel like I need to do well again before I can enjoy anything. That’s what got me thinking seriously about quitting.
PETE: I don’t know if I could start from scratch now. I had all the time in the world in my 20s. Now I think about having a bad day and coming home in a daze while my kid’s trying to ask me something.
KROW: Sometimes my kid will point at something and ask what it is and I can’t even come up with the word. I’m still thinking about trading. It’s very hard to reconcile, especially if you aren’t making money–you can’t even give yourself the excuse that you’re providing for them.
PETE: How black-and-white are the signals in your current strategy?
KROW: Pretty black-and-white. There’s still some discretion, and I think most manual trading will always need some of that. I try to make it as black-and-white as possible because that suits my personality.
For stock selection, I still look at fundamentals, technicals, the stock’s history, price, float, market cap, country, and so on. I’ve had mentors who leaned more discretionary and others who were somewhere in between. I’ve also traded pure if-then systems.
PETE: Are you shorting the frontside, the backside, or the opening print?
KROW: Backside only right now. I’ve traded the opening print2(this means shorting the 9:30 opening print and having some fixed percentage-based stop–excuse me while I step aside and puke at the thought) and the frontside before, but I don’t do either anymore, at least for now.
PETE: What signals the backside for you?
KROW: Once I’ve decided a stock is in play, I look for about four to six different signals or conditions. Each one adds another layer of confirmation as I work toward a full position.
The signal itself isn’t that important to me. I want to find the area where I’d like to get involved, then find something visual that shows it to me consistently. I’ve experimented with enough indicators and timeframes that I can get most of them to show me roughly the same entry. Ultimately, I’m looking for a combination of conditions that suggests a potential top, with my risk controlled if I’m wrong.
PETE: Any particular risk management or sizing rules?
KROW: I’m pretty consistent with sizing. I try to risk the same amount per play, which I determine as a set percentage of my equity.
PETE: In your own words, what do you think has held you back?
KROW: I’ve thought about this a lot and my answer would have changed depending on what stage I was at.
At first, I thought I just needed a mentor. Then I got help from people traders would kill to learn from. I’m talking about some of the best traders in the small cap circle–guys who make 8 figures and keep it to themselves. I tried their styles and spent a lot of time trying to analyze their every decision. Those mentorships ended without me being able to achieve profitability.

In 2024, I would blame it on discretion, switching styles, or discipline. Now I don’t think those are the hurdles because I have committed to a system and I execute with discipline. I’ve executed a failing system for long enough to know that I can stick with one.
PETE: Can you get more into your relationships with your mentors? Why do you feel there was a gap between what they taught you and your ability to turn a profit in trading?
KROW: I’ve had two official mentorships, I would say, where I was really taken on day to day for extended periods of time. Both put significant effort into showing me everything about their styles, with the plan to really bring me up. Both were well into eight figures.
While I was shown everything, both have a lot of discretionary elements to their trading that I couldn’t seem to replicate. I have a brain that tries to exploit any gap in understanding or ambiguity, and I have limited fear of taking a loss. So if something has a ~5% chance of being the setup I’m studying, I’m going to take it because I want to get my reps in and understand through experience. But I just couldn’t seem to form a decision web strong enough to be profitable trading that way in the time I had with them. To me, too many things looked like a possible setup, no matter how much I tried to study and review.
I’ve also had what I view as significant support from many others, ranging from seven-figure to eight-figure traders, both individually and through various rooms and pods along the way. And although he wouldn’t consider it a mentorship, the person I view as my longest “mentor” has been there for me through a lot. He’s given me tangible trading support, as well as mental support at my lows, and my current system is built around his trading style.
PETE: Do you still trade with a like-minded pod or friend?
I do, yes. I trade every day with a friend, and we’ve tuned our systems to be basically identical. He makes money and does quite well. I can explain some of my results this year. I put money into the account when I thought I was hitting my stride and went straight into a bad cycle. The losses were bigger than the wins I’d had before. There’s always something I can point to, but it’s always something different. I don’t believe I can make money trading anymore. It doesn’t change how I execute. I’m still here every day, almost out of curiosity. I’m ready to face the music but also asking the market “Prove me wrong?”.

I just have this genuine incapability of filtering which stocks to apply rules to beyond what is possible through black-and-white definitions. I believe that’s such an underrated component of trading, and it will nearly always come down to discretion (unless you’re algo trading). You can have an S-tier execution system and all the discipline in the world, but if you’re not applying it to the right stocks, it just won’t work over extended periods of time.
This is like one of those studies of twins raised in different households. You’re both trading basically the same system, but he’s making money and you’re losing. Assuming execution and psychology aren’t the issue, where’s the difference coming from? Is it sizing up at the wrong time? Picking the wrong stock at the open?
PETE: Can you drill down on a day where you traded the same stock and he made money and you didn’t?
KROW: Day to day, our results are actually pretty similar. Sometimes I outperform him. Then you look at the quarter and my chart is down and his is up. We both have concentrated wins. My results in R can be positive and it still doesn’t translate into money after fees and locates.
PETE: I know a guy who did great backtesting and understood the system. But he’d tell me every time we took the same trade, it would fail, but when I took it by myself, it worked. Over time, he developed a negative psyche and started thinking he had this reverse Midas touch–everything he touches turns to shit. With your friend trading an identical strategy, that’s about as good a feedback loop as you can get in trading. Can you pull up, say, ten trading days, and see where the P&Ls actually diverge?
KROW: We do come to some tentative conclusions. The problem is there’s always a new conclusion. “I got unlucky with the market cycle right as I sized up” or something like that. Right now I feel like I’ve got everything set up and ready to execute but then the market opportunities dried up. I could switch to something else I have data on, but then I think the small cap market will come back and I’ll miss it. If I stay and try to be patient, I’m sitting through another three empty months like this. If I switch, I’m telling myself I shouldn’t have drifted again. It really is what you said–this reverse Midas touch.

PETE: You’re unlike many in the small cap space who get blown up in 1-2 trades, which ends up being their defining low moment. What has felt like your lowest moment so far?
KROW: Earlier this year I was ready to quit, so I traded a tiny account for three months. I just wanted to execute and see what happened. I felt clearheaded. I’d get up at 4 a.m., trade, and get on with my day. My wife noticed I wasn’t bringing trading into everything anymore. I’d told her the results were good, and she offered to put some money in. I never would’ve asked her on my own. I deposited it after three profitable months, then hit the worst cycle after sizing up with the extra money. I wiped out the positive streak and went right back into drawdown. I know the timing was unlucky, but it felt awful to lose money she’d given me.
PETE: Have you ever put this much time and effort into anything else?
KROW: Martial arts and gaming, maybe, but those were hobbies. When I was done, I was done. I’d been looking for something I could put everything into and try to master. Trading ticked all those boxes. I’d study fifteen hours a day, fill up notepads, and review charts all the time. Up until last year, it was really painful to watch myself draw down after putting that much time into it. I’ve accepted it more this year, but it’s still the first thing I’ve put this much of myself into.
Sometimes I’ll think about this guy I used to train martial arts with. He was in the same class four times a week, and after a year he hadn’t gotten better. He kept showing up. I wonder if I’m that guy in trading–maybe I just don’t have *whatever the thing is* that the consistently profitable traders have. I’m still going to execute and see what happens, regardless.
I think about this exact thing when I’m struggling with billiards. There are people who stay at the same beginner handicap—somewhere between a 2 and a 4—for like a decade. Some are just there for fun and drink a lot and that’s that. Others have three cues that cost $1,000 each and have taken lessons from pros, and they’re still an APA 4. And I wonder if some people are just fated for that exhausting, Sisyphean experience. It makes me think I don’t have any agency over my own improvement, that it’s all talent and fate. Then I remind myself to take a breath and forget all that, because thinking that way won’t help me.
PETE: Do you have any theories on whether shorting small caps got too hard? It’s certainly a popular take in small cap discourse right now.
KROW: I definitely feel like it has. I feel like as a trader I have improved exponentially over the years, but the difficulty in the space has increased even faster, invalidating my own improvements to some degree. It actually ties into why I feel I won’t make money, because I remain a step behind. In the time it takes me to make a tangible improvement, the window for profitability shrinks as competition increases, basically negating the progress I made toward that “profitability line.”

Overall, I think the market feels more difficult than ever. If I traded how I trade now back in 2021, or even 2023 or 2024, I would have made seven figures or more, without a doubt in my mind. But unfortunately, I cannot trade history. Unless those markets repeat themselves, my skill set won’t mean a thing. With how things are going, especially with locate prices going up, I don’t really see it happening.
I do think certain edges have diminished or, speaking from a data perspective, require significant adjustment. Also, I believe a lot of these edges were never meant to be permanent anyway, so is it really a surprise? Maybe the market was behaving in a way that was out of the norm, and certain styles, pushed to the extreme, could have made a lot of money in the last couple of years. Would it have been the same in more common market conditions? I don’t know. Maybe, in the big picture, things are just going through their larger natural cycle, and those “diminished” edges will be able to be pressed again in a few more years.
Personally, I’ve been in small caps since 2010, and I definitely think it’s gotten harder. That’s a big reason why I stopped. If it were still easy for me to make $5k/day, I’d keep doing it even if I hated it. At this point, I don’t know how you approach it without being an absolute master of the market—ultra-quick, able to read liquidity across multiple timeframes, and constantly adjusting. A lot of the old mental models I once used don’t seem to hold up anymore–and this is validated statistically as well.
PETE: How much longer are you going to give it?
KROW: It was supposed to be the end of 2026. If the equity curve wasn’t heading up, I was done. Now I’m saying I finally got everything in line and it’s a bad market for it, so let’s give it the first quarter of 2027. Then it’s, “Maybe give it all of 2027.” Realistically, I’m not losing much now. I know the system and it’s fairly simple to execute. I basically made an “I quit” post on Twitter, and here I am–still trading.

If I have a system I can execute without it costing me much money or taking over my head, I can see the logic in seeing it through. But I don’t want to be the guy at the slot machine saying, “This time’s going to be the one.” I don’t want to be that guy in ten years.
PETE: Can I post the “I quit” post?
KROW: Sure.
What would you sacrifice to become a successful trader? If you asked me any time since I began, the answer would be “everything.” However, what we do not consider, is that as we grow, our lives expand, and those who we love naturally inherit this unwavering commitment. This dream becomes less and less romantic, and more of a burden that drags down everybody around you.
Trading is the worst endeavor I’ve ever attempted to pursue, and the only thing I can say I’ve truly given my everything to. I would never recommend this to anybody.
6 years of absolute misery, putting every part of myself into this dream, sacrificing relationships, career advancement, health, and time I will never get back with my two young boys. I can’t think of anything more exposing of my lack of personal judgement, as well as my incompetence as a person to achieve what I set out to do, which – unfortunately – translates directly to my value as a person, and the reality that my family has to live with my failures due to no fault of their own.
This isn’t a cry for help. At this point I wouldn’t take it, because I know with absolute certainty the investment in me would amount to nothing, and just be another person I let down. What is even more comical about all of this is I have personally already received direct mentorship, and access who others would kill for, in various styles, and yet due to my ineptitude I still couldn’t produce results.
As much as others would like you to believe, putting the time in isn’t always the answer. Trading isn’t for everybody. And no matter how much of a prodigy you believe you are, just know every single person before you has thought the exact same. Truly think about if this is what you want to do, and be aware of the pain ahead.
The only silver lining to trading for me, is the connections and truly great people I have met along the way. The shared pain and isolation of pursuing trading has the potential to create connections that you are very unlikely to form in any other setting if you allow it. I will never forget any of those that were there for me when I was at my lowest, and I will carry the regret forever of not being able to return the help each one provided. Thank you all, and I am truly sorry.
This post is so people can see the true reality for many that pursue this, and not the romanticized version plastered all over your feed. I will now take back my life, mend my relationships, rebuild with those that I love, and enjoy the simple life awaiting me, for I already have more than the millions could have bought anyway.
Good luck.
I think you said some raw things that need to be heard. You can find what you think is your niche, get good help, execute without blowing up, and still have it not work. The hardest part to me is that fog of war where you’re on your 178th tweak to the system and doubting your own sanity for even thinking anything can work at that point. I appreciate you being this candid. Thanks to Krow for being part of Churning and Chatting and sharing his struggles. Best of luck to him.

Well, this guy is a struggler and keeps blowing up his account. But there is other side which breakeven. That hasn’t occurred after trading for six years. I wish he would keep on trading. Thanks for sharing his story.